tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post8650371150968407978..comments2024-03-17T16:13:55.262-07:00Comments on Blobs in Games: Auction HousesAmithttp://www.blogger.com/profile/12159325271882018300noreply@blogger.comBlogger6125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post-50754209733068490202013-08-10T10:31:43.683-07:002013-08-10T10:31:43.683-07:00Hey Amit, Check out the way runescape does it with...Hey Amit, Check out the way runescape does it with their grand exchange. Sounds similar to what you're talking about. Jhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/16405499976185645390noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post-27657234026335317332012-10-12T21:20:56.428-07:002012-10-12T21:20:56.428-07:00Rob C: I think it depends on what problem you want...Rob C: I think it depends on what problem you want to solve. If you want to make trading a fun subgame (especially for sellers), then I agree (as I noted at the end of the blog post), inefficiency and locality are good. If on the other hand you are using the auction to set prices, then a simpler market might work better.Amithttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12159325271882018300noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post-7782013245413014102012-10-12T14:22:55.201-07:002012-10-12T14:22:55.201-07:00While designing an efficient market is a cool puzz...While designing an efficient market is a cool puzzle to solve for a programmer, sometimes it's the inefficiencies that make the game.<br /><br />Take something like Diablo 3 for instance, I would heartily argue that one of it's failings is that despite it's auction house's flaws, it's too efficient. <br /><br />The more efficient player trading becomes, the more marginally beneficial it is compared to playing the game. In a game like Path of Exile, player trading is incredibly cumbersome, (no real currency, no easy transfer between players, few obviously good items, no auction house or offline trading) and because of that, nearly everything you get probably comes from monsters that you defeat. Items that you get that are obviously good for someone else, but not you, probably get sold to vendors or at best stashed for alts because it's too hard to sell them unless they're unbelievably incredible.<br /><br />On the other hand, consider Diablo 3, where anything that's obviously good can get sold on the auction house, and so far more things get placed on the auction house than actually get used. This drives prices down, expectations up, and creates a real buyer's market. Items far stronger than what you are likely to find from playing become affordable, and soon the best way to "play" the game is to actually buy low, sell high, and never swing a sword unless you have to. <br /><br />I guess it's a cool problem to solve, but is it a problem best left unsolved?Rob Cnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post-87549354287179509132012-08-10T09:38:26.744-07:002012-08-10T09:38:26.744-07:00Nelson: geographic economics is a fascinating topi...Nelson: geographic economics is a fascinating topic; I've only read a little bit from a textbook and it influenced one of the games I was working on. Eve Online seems to do this pretty well, but I think it requires travel/transport to be expensive to make it interesting.<br /><br />Rick C: nice! I've not played that game.Amithttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12159325271882018300noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post-18830055016592227162012-07-03T07:25:16.891-07:002012-07-03T07:25:16.891-07:00If I understand it correctly, the Wizard101 auctio...If I understand it correctly, the Wizard101 auction house works like this: if you want to buy something, say, a stack of reagents, it tells you the min and max prices for how many you tell it you want, and it'll buy as many as it needs to (or can, if someone beats you) starting with the cheapest ones.Rick Cnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5052387.post-87462387424296794002012-06-16T20:31:08.872-07:002012-06-16T20:31:08.872-07:00The Eve Online markets are worth a look. Buyers ar...The Eve Online markets are worth a look. Buyers are still faced with the same confusing "list of all auctions" thing, only in Eve it's useful because the location of the items is important. But what's nice is buyers can place buy orders too, letting the sellers come in and fill them later. Works great for commodity resources.<br /><br />The WoW auction house is pretty bad. The Diablo AH is even worse; auctions are for 36 hours and there is no way to cancel them. Also, sellers are limited to only 10 auctions for sale. So there's a strong temptation to underprice things just so they move and a slot is free to sell something else. Grr. OTOH the Diablo auction house did get commodity auctions right; they automatically help you find the lowest price for commodity goods like gems.Nelsonhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13183364513305941382noreply@blogger.com